CHAPTER FIVE – HOBBY SHOP

Today would have been my father’s hundredth birthday, and I haven’t been able to get him out of my head. He was a sweet man, always encouraging, but often abstracted by problems from work he couldn’t seem to leave at the office. He spent most of his career as an industrial designer at Merz Tool in Portland, Oregon, where I grew up. My father led the product design team at Merz and generally seemed to enjoy his work, despite its spillage into his home life. But then he hit the wall with a project he’d been working on for the last years. I was in junior high school at the time and my father, approaching sixty, with an eye to early retirement.

He had designed the prototype for an aluminum shipping pallet, utilizing recycled aluminum, with implications for the company and worldwide shipping that were enormous. Five hundred million wooden pallets are manufactured every year and more than 90% of freight relies on them.

His aluminum pallet offered comparable strength and support to the wooden at a fraction of the weight. My father described his Alum Pallet ® as a win-win that would lower shipping costs as well as reduce Co2 emissions, save forests, and be fully recyclable. It was estimated at the time that more than 5% of wooden pallets end up in landfills. I was proud of my dad for being an early conservationist. In some ways, he was ahead of his time.

The lobbies of the lumber and pallet industries, which were particularly strong in the Pacific Northwest, erected the roadblock he encountered year after year. I didn’t understand how an industry could block the production of a product, till it was explained to me that that was the price of doing business. All these years later, aluminum pallets do exist, but the fact that they represent barely a blip on the world market testifies to the ongoing power of those lobbies.

My father had a favorite phrase: “The rich and powerful regard progress as a gilded spittoon, a gaudy receptacle for their spittle.” He liked to invent phrases that had a patina of majesty and sounded iconic. Sometimes they juggled mixed metaphors or dubious logic, but they always amused me. My father was a great reader and admirer of the English language but whenever he had to write an abstract for work it was clotted with complex sentences, parenthetical phrases that branched off like spreading vines. After complaints at work he began having my mother, a high school English teacher go over his pages. He wouldn’t let anybody at Merz, especially the professional writers, mess with his copy. My mother untangled the language, distilling it into lucid sentences, which to his mind lost all of his style.

One winter evening when it was dark at 6:00, I walked into the kitchen during my parents’ cocktail hour. They stood at the Formica counter, their usual spot. One of my father’s reports lay on the counter beside a jar of creamed herring. They each had their own forks and stabbed at the herring filets. My father drank a tumbler of Old Crow on a single rock, just like his father had, and my mother, a good fifteen years younger than him, nursed a whiskey sour. She had it in a stemmed glass that she held like a model, her prized pearl ring, set in a dimpled sheet of sterling silver, shining on her arched finger. My parents didn’t mind me being around during cocktail hour. I had the privilege, as the only child, to assume the role of the third adult at the bar. I cruised the counter and tore off a hunk of Larabaru French bread and grabbed butter from the fridge.

I had the privilege, as the only child,

to assume the role of the third adult at the bar.

“Gilbert,” my mother said, and plucked out another filet, “you’re tying yourself up in knots with this foolish idea that you can bring style to industrial writing.” I watched her drop the herring into her mouth. A drop of sour cream feathered across her upper lip and she blotted it with a napkin. “What this writing need, Gilbert, is clarity. If you want style, write a novel. Then you can compete with James Joyce in obfuscation.”

“But not in style,” my father said, his brown eyes fluttering in a brief shadow of remorse.

I chewed on my bread and, after I swallowed it, winked at my mother, “So on my next birthday I can start drinking whiskey. Right?” It was a joke I’d come up with when I was eight or nine that I kicked along like an old stone into my teens. My parents always played along.

“So what do you suppose you’ll fancy,” my father asked, “scotch or bourbon?”

“Bourbon, of course.”

“That’s my boy.”

The truth is I never took a liking to bourbon or whiskey of any kind. Pina has introduced me to cocktails and I’ll have one with her occasionally to be sociable. One of these nights I’m going to pull out a jar of creamed herring and hand her a fork.

The upshot of my father’s frustration with his job was his notion that he needed a hobby and, curiously, he came to me, his thirteen-year-old son, for advice. As a dedicated nerd, I’d been assembling model cars and airplanes out of kits from the time I was seven or eight, and by junior high, when I had two paper routes to fund the kits, I’d put together a clipper ship and a destroyer, as well as a life-size human torso, dedicated to the body’s musculature and digestive system. It consisted of 444 pieces. In some ways I was a little slow for my age. While my buddies were leering at girlie magazine at the drugstore in Goose Hollow, I was still hanging out at the hobby store.

My father lauded the meticulousness of my work. “Charlie, God, they say, is in the details. Even us nonbelievers can see their virtue.”

By the time my father approached me, I’d begun doing some woodworking; I figured that with a little skill I could build and even design my own cars and not have to follow somebody else’s directions.

So one Saturday he found me seated at the workbench in the basement. He appreciated the VW Bug I’d been carving out of a large block of basswood. I remember he particularly admired my work on the car’s doors, which actually opened and shut without a hitch.

“Charlie, you’ve taught yourself to be a master carver in no time at all. You are a very clever boy.”

I think his praise embarrassed me because I said, “No, no, they say that basswood is the most forgiving wood, and if I had any genuine talent I’d be carving a ’57 T Bird with the portholes, or a finny ’63 Fleetwood. A VW Bug is simple, like carving a cupcake.”

“Not at all,” he protested. “For a boy your age, I’d say you’re demonstrating

preternatural wisdom. Aren’t we living in the age of less–is-more? Point of fact: It was the German architect Mies van der Rohe who coined that phrase back in the forties. After he immigrated to America, he only required three things to be happy: martinis, Dunhill cigars, and expensive clothes. And closer to home, at Lewis and Clark we have William Stafford, who says he has no problem with writer’s block as long as he’s willing to keep his standards low enough. Once you get the basic form down you can add nuance.”

For a boy your age, I’d say you’re

demonstrating preternatural wisdom

My father could dazzle with an endless thread of cultural minutia.

“I have no worries about you, Charlie,” he continued, “you will always find your way. Now give me an idea of a suitable hobby for the likes of me. A man doesn’t want to die sitting in front of his television set.”

I knew my father to be a talented welder and woodworker but he said he wanted something removed from previous experience. I thought about things people did as hobbies. He clearly wasn’t the stamp or coin collector type. I couldn’t see him taking up golf or bowling. Photography might be an option. “How about writing a novel, dad?” I said, like I was onto something.

“Oh, I couldn’t do that.”

“You just need to keep your standards low enough,” I echoed. “Arrive at a basic form and then add nuance.”

After he retired, he took to novel writing. I never got to see anything he wrote at the time. Whenever I asked to see what he’d been writing he’d say, “Oh, no yet, not yet. An old man’s mind can become as tightly wound as a hairball, and I haven’t yet figured out how to effectively lower my standards.”

Sadly, my father died only a couple years after his retirement. In his will he made me his literary executor—talk about a dubious distinction—and left a six hundred-page manuscript, titled “The Miscalculation of Hector Rose, or The Aluminum Tree.” I’m ashamed to say that in the forty years since his death, I haven’t managed to get past page five. I see that as a rather large failure on my part, which I’m unable to explain.

My mother read the book a few years before she died, and said, “Well, yes, your father has style. But let’s keep the book in the family.”

My father died, by the way, just as he hoped not to, sitting in front of the television set, laughing so hard at an episode of “Mork and Mindy” that he fatally choked.

Fortunately, I was able to retire much earlier than he did, but also found myself casting around for the right hobby. I bought a sailboat, which I still keep in Sausalito, but I realized I couldn’t sail every day. I spent a few years building things that didn’t interest me. I think it was because those projects represented finite challenges like elaborate jigsaw puzzles not missing a single piece. I was reminded of my best buddy from Industrial Light and Magic, Herb Pivnick. “For a Jew,” he told me once, “perfection is unthinkable. To create something deemed perfect is to have built an idol.”

“For a Jew,” he told me once,

“perfection is unthinkable.

To create something deemed

perfect is to have built an idol.”

I spent a year or two trying to construct problems that were insoluble, but there was artifice in each of these enterprises that made me feel like I was operating in poor faith.

Finally, I discovered Roscoe, whose limits I will never reach. There is grace even for a nonbeliever, as my father might have said, in a hobby that leads me staggering into the unknown with a bird that can think. If nothing else, I believe my old man would be cheered by the parrot’s intellect, not to speak of his prowess with language. Happy 100th, dad.

 

CHAPTER FOUR – CHERRIES

I heard my nonna’s voice coming from outside my childhood home, and rushed from my bed to the window. She stood beside a disorderly silver maple, dressed in her black widow garb, except for an uncharacteristic straw hat, ringed in faux cherries. I threw on one of Charlie’s flannel shirts but didn’t bother buttoning it. Down two flights of stairs to the street took an eternity. I could still hear her voice—it was all its verticality, climbing up and down the laddered rungs of her throat.

She sang out in spiky Italian: Il mondo sta volgendo al termine, the world is coming to an end. I put on a mask at the front door. Charlie is always making new ones, this one from a print with cherries and their stems. Sometimes the world aligns in harmonic convergence. This must be one of those times.

When I reached the street, my nonna was nowhere to be seen, but Charlie’s daughter Sally stood under the silver maple with a colander filled with wet, glistening cherries. A blood-red scar of cherry juice spread like a birthmark across her face. She kept shoving cherries into her mouth and spitting out the seeds.

“Have you seen an old woman?” I asked.

“I haven’t see anybody. I keep to myself.” Sally wiped her mouth with the back of her hand and now it, too, looked like a great wound.

(c) Chester Arnold, 2020

“It was my nonna,” I said, “my grandmother.”

Sally spit out some seeds. “How old is she?”

I stopped to do the math. “One hundred and fifteen.”

“She must be on a salt-free diet and mainlining Vitamin D. I know for a fact that she’s ingesting plenty of fiber.”

Apparently, Sally had eaten enough cherries because she now picked them out of the colander and began throwing them at passing cars.

I was overcome with sadness at the prospect of not seeing my nonna again, and decided to go back in the house, but when I turned from the street, the house was gone.

Sally’s scream woke me. Charlie had already left for his early morning walk. When I got out to the living room, Sally was pacing back and forth, barefoot in flannel pajamas, mumbling to herself. I caught her eye and asked what the matter was. She looked back at me as if I should know. “That bird,” she said finally.

“He scared you?”

“Well, yes. I woke, sat up in the futon, and that bird said, ‘Top of the morning to you,’ in a fucking Irish brogue, and when he saw me freaking out, he said, ‘Is everything copasetic, dear?’ in a voice that sounded like my Aunt Emily’s. That’s when I screamed. Sorry about that.”

“No worries. Yeah, your dad’s really got Roscoe trained to say all kinds of shit. It is pretty spooky.”

“How can a bird do that?”

“Ah, now you’re asking questions too deep for me to answer. You know the person to ask.”

I brewed a pot of coffee and Sally and I sat apart from each other out on the deck. The fog had come in and it was nippy outside. I want to help Sally feel comfortable, not just about Roscoe, but about staying in her father’s house, with me around. That will be a trick because it’s not something that I’m comfortable with.

I gazed into Sally’s pretty moon face and the fetching gap between her front teeth. Her coloring is much darker than Charlie’s, and yet I can see a likeness around her eyes. As I sipped my coffee, I tried to imagine what it will be like for her to start over in the middle of a plague, and found myself thinking about the mess I was after Marco, my late husband died.

Sally smiled at me. “Where’d you go?”

Her question surprised me. It wasn’t as if we were in the middle of a conversation.

“You don’t have to tell me, but I noticed your mind take off on a jet and fly from one hemisphere to another.”

I shook my head. “You could see that? Are you clairvoyant, Sally?”

“Hmm,” she said, cryptically, before changing the subject. “Hey, I can tell that you’re good for my dad,”

“How so?”

“Well, for one thing, I haven’t noticed him smile so much in years.”

“I think he was just glad to see you, Sally.”

“Nah. He seems younger and like he’s got some kind of purpose.”

“His purpose is Roscoe.”

“Why don’t you want to believe what I’m telling you. Pina?” she asked, as if she were the elder.

“I don’t know . . . it makes me bashful.”

Sally laughed at that.

“What? Am I too old to be bashful?”

“Shush. I see the way the two of you look at each other. ‘Nuff said.”

“Maybe we were just putting on a show for you.”

Sally shook her head, as if I were hopeless. She finished her coffee and stood. “It’s time for my yoga practice. I want to see what that bird has to say when I stand on my head for fifteen minutes.”

“I can bring him out to the living room.”

“No, no, I need to make peace with Roscoe.”

I stayed out on the deck until Charlie returned from his walk, musing about the idea that somebody might love me, and my resistance to it.

This morning Sonoma is the second coming of Pompeii—flakes of ash falling from a yellow orange sky. We saw images of San Francisco in complete darkness at ten in the morning. In Sonoma the air quality reading was surprisingly decent. Apparently the smoke had risen very high in the atmosphere. A layer of marine air (I think that means fog) served as a buffer.

Charlie and I walked to the square. People carried on as if all this was normal. Deliveries were made to restaurants operating at quarter capacity. Tourists window-shopped in their masks. When weirdness becomes the norm you either roll with the punches or go mad.

It’s been two weeks now since Sally’s moved in. Charlie and I have danced around the inconvenience and we both know something has to give. The condo is too small for three people and a parrot in the middle of a plague.

Charlie took my hand and led me over to the duck pond—the site of our first meeting. We sat on the same bench, but no longer six feet apart. A single mallard glided around the pond and Charlie commented on him: “Everybody is a little lonely these days.”

I agreed. Since Sally moved in, I’ve felt unbalanced in a way that reminds me of loneliness. Lonely in a crowd. I asked Charlie how his work with Roscoe was going.

“I wouldn’t call it work,” he said.

“What would you call it? You’re in there with him for eight hours a day.” I didn’t like how that came out; it sounded so bitchy.

Charlie offered a thin-lipped smile. “Roscoe has an insatiable appetite for language.”

“So you’re feeding him words eight hours a day.” That too sounded bitchy. I couldn’t help myself.

Thankfully, Charlie changed the subject. “I’ve rented an apartment for Sally in Sonoma. It’s a really nice place, down on Broadway. I haven’t told her yet. I wanted you to know first. The problem is she can’t get in until October first.”

“That’s three more weeks. Maybe I’ll move back into Vince’s condo until she moves out.”

“Or I could take a driving trip with Sally,” Charlie said. He had a skeptical look on his face as the idea of the driving trip unfurled. “Okay, let’s see, because of the fires you can’t drive north, can’t drive south, and west you have the Pacific Ocean.“

“Sounds like you’re heading east young man, with your girl and your parrot.” Somehow saying this set us both off laughing. I hadn’t laughed so hard for a long time, not in modern memory, and the unspoken tension between Charlie and me lifted at least as high as the marine layer.

Sally was thrilled to hear the news about the apartment Charlie rented for her and said that she’d be happy to cook dinner. I didn’t look forward to the prospect and ended up chiding myself for assuming that whatever she cooked would resemble hippie chow.

I wasn’t far off. Sally made an African peanut stew that was moderately palatable. Along with a preponderance of peanut butter, she added sweet potatoes, brown rice, and collard greens from her garden. Before leaving the Lost Coast, she filled the back seat of her car with her harvest, and we are still in possession of more collards and kale than any three people could eat in six months. This dish was definitely stick to your ribs type fare, but I’m not sure whether my ribs will ever be the same.

“Any ideas for a wine pairing?” Charlie asked.

I suggested the heartiest red in Charlie’s cellar but Charlie doesn’t have a cellar and the only decent red we had on hand was an Oregon Pinot, which didn’t have nearly the tannin or starch to stand up to the stew.

Charlie, compensating for my polite response, was full of compliments for Sally’s dinner.

“Sally never used to cook,” he said.

“I cook all the time now.”

“Remember how you’d say, a contemporary woman should not spend any time cooking, because that reinforces the stereotype that a woman’s place is in the kitchen.”

“Yeah,” Sally said, shrugging, ”I said a lot of stupid shit, but at least there was some logic in the thought.”

“So you’ve evolved,” Charlie said.

“Or devolved.” Sally aimed a fat forkful of peanut stew into her mouth.

Charlie smiled at me and at his daughter. He clearly looked like a happy man. And, yes, I am beginning to believe he loves me.

Sally blotted her lips with her napkin. “I think we should do raw tomorrow night. I’m thinking a raw vegan lasagna.”

Neither Charlie nor I responded and I sat there trying to come up with the perfect wine pairing.

“Or should we do broccoli balls and cauliflower rice sushi?”

CHAPTER THREE – THE VOICE

Last night before dinner there was a knock on the door. Pina and I were not expecting anybody, and unexpected visitors are truly a thing of the past. We were sipping Negronis out on the deck. Smoke from the fires had blown east and the air quality, at least according to our phones was rated as Good. Neither of us wanted to answer the door. The knock came again. I stood up and put on a mask.

“You don’t have to answer it,” Pina said. “It’s probably a Jehovah’s Witness. Nothing stops them.”

But by then I was curious. I pulled the door open and stood back in one motion, a maneuver I’ve perfected over the last months when deliveries have come. And there stood Sally, my beautiful daughter, mask less, and forcing a sad gap-toothed smile. I wanted to hug her but knew better.

And there stood Sally, my beautiful daughter,

mask less, and forcing a sad gap-toothed smile.

I wanted to hug her but knew better.

“What are you doing here?” I said instead.

“Aren’t you going to invite me in, Dad?”

I stood on my spot for a minute. “I can’t. I have my friend, Pina, here. We’re in the midst of a pandemic.”

“Did you forget that I live in the middle of nowhere? I haven’t seen anybody except Alger for ages.”

“Don’t you have a mask? What happened to all the masks I sent you?”

“They aren’t necessary where I live, but they’re beautiful, Dad. We hung them across the living room wall.”

“Well, you’ll need a mask down here.”

Sally, dressed in faded jeans and an embroidered peasant tunic, nodded and then shifted her weight from one foot to the other. She wore the same exasperated expression I remember from her teen years, but it’s been a good ten years since she was a teen. Her backpack hung from her right shoulder and she gave it a boost to keep it from slipping down her arm.

“Stay here,” I said. “Let me explain things to Pina.”

Pina was remarkably magnanimous. “Of course, have her come in. She’s your daughter. I look forward to meeting her. We’ll keep our distance.”

“But, we don’t know where she’s been.”

“Didn’t you say she lives on the Lost Coast?” Pina said, as if this fact carried immunity with it.

I brought Sally a fresh mask in a baggie and a small bottle of hand sanitizer. “Here, put this on and don’t touch anything when you come in.”

Sally sneered at me before putting on the mask, which I made from a fabric                 that featured oversized black polka dots, giving her visage a clownish aspect. As she walked in, Sally stuck her hands in the air as if she were under arrest.

“And don’t be a smartass,” I said, just to insure, I suppose, that she’d be a smartass. I wanted Pina to see my daughter as she is, although she’d become a mystery to me years ago.

After I offered the whole liquor cabinet, Sally asked for a beer. Pina sat bright-eyed in the goldenrod director’s chair with her second Negroni. I stood beside my pygmy Meyer lemon tree, and Sally slouched in the faded forest green chair after pulling a joint from a zippered pocket at the top of her pack.

“So you’re Pina. My dad told me all about you, but I don’t remember a thing he said. I’ve been under a lot of stress.”

So you’re Pina. My dad told me all about you,

but I don’t remember a thing he said.

I craned my neck toward Sally to see if I could make her recoil. “So what’s been going on?”

She dodged my question. “Did you tell me how pretty Pina was?”

“I don’t remember what I told you.”

“See,” Sally said, “it runs in our family. Nobody remembers anything.”

“I don’t remember anything either,” Pina said. “But that may be my drinking. There’s no hope for me, Sally. You mind if I join you?” Pina fished around in the pocket of her white camp shirt and pulled out a doob. “The only creature that remembers anything around here is your father’s damn parrot.”

“Ba dum ching!” Sally sat up straight and, before lighting her joint, softened it between the flat of her hands. Pina lit hers directly. They each took long tokes and exhaled through their nostrils, sorority sisters from the start. I pulled out another director’s chair and decided to enjoy my irrelevance.

“You’re lucky you weren’t around for my dad’s hamster days.” Sally said, sinking back into a deep slouch.

“His hamster days.”

“Yeah, I was a six-year-old kid who wanted a hamster and the next thing I knew my dad founded a colony of them. He built an enormous cage on a platform in our basement and constructed elaborate Ferris wheels, slides, and spinning disks. We called it the hamster circus.”

Pina smiled and passed me her joint. “Your father is an inspired man.”

“I guess so,” Sally allowed, “but weird.”

I relit the joint, which had gone out.

“Nice to see you smoking, Dad. I can tell that Pina’s been a good influence on you.”

Pina laughed so hard that she ended up with the hiccups. I have to say the smoke relaxed me. I hadn’t smoked for years before Pina came on the scene. It used to make me paranoid; now, I assumed, I was too old for paranoia.

Meanwhile Sally looked like she’d gotten comfortable on the deck. I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop but I decided to let her lay her cards on the table when she wanted. Reckless, no doubt, Pina and I decided to bond with her, when she claimed she’d not been physically in the world with anybody for three weeks, since Alger left on a trip. She’d stopped working for the cannabis company up the road from her place, early in the pandemic. She lived off her garden, all that she’d pickled and canned, and the treasures in her freezer.

“We haven’t been with anybody either,” Pina said. “Just keeping each other company.”

Pina was ready to do the bonding thing before me, but Sally was my daughter. May as well live and die with your own.

“You must be careful,” I admonished. “If you’re going to stay here at all, you can’t be hanging out with other people. “Don’t forget, Sally, we’re old people.”

“I’ve become a recluse after all the years on the Lost Coast. I haven’t hung out with people for a long time.”

“Let’s be safe,” I said. “We wear our masks when we’re not eating or drinking or smoking. And we keep our distance.”

We had dinner out on the deck. Pina made a tasty mushroom and herb omelet and I tossed a salad of little gems. Sally looked truly happy for the first time since she arrived and preceded to air every grievance she had about growing up with me as her father: forcing her to eat her Brussels sprouts and making her clean her room every week if she wanted to get her allowance. “I mean, it was like five dollars a week, so there wasn’t a whole lot of incentive. I felt like I lived in a debtor ‘s prison.”

“Do you think I should have raised your allowance when you didn’t clean your room very often?”

Sally stuck out her tongue at me. But after that, to my surprise, most of her complaints were tepid and taken together they created the portrait of a man who, despite being eccentric, was not without his charms.

Pina seemed to revel in all the stories about me as a dad, especially the ones about my taking Sally every Sunday to Ginsberg’s Galley, a poetry karaoke bar in Guerneville that evolved into a poetry church.

“What was that reverend’s name?” Sally asked.

“Bobby Sabbatini.”

“Right. Before Sabbatini saw the light and fell in love with poetry, he had been a police detective.”

“That’s what we need in these times,” Pina said, “more cops who love poetry.”

“Yeah, but those were weird people out there,” Sally said, rolling her eyes, “absolute river rats.”

I wondered if the good people along the Russian River were any weirder than the people Sally ran into on the Lost Coast.

“Every damn week we had to haul ass out to Guerneville, to listen to people recite poems. I think my dad had the idea he was giving me religion.”

“Every damn week we had to haul ass out to Guerneville,

to listen to people recite poems.”

“Hey, it was right after your mom left and, I admit, I was searching for something.”

“But all the way out to Guerneville,” Sally said.

“You were just pissed that nobody was reciting Shel Silverstein poems.”

Sally held up a finger to indicate that her mouth was full. I gazed at my lovely daughter and forgot for the moment where we were and what we were talking about. Sally doesn’t look much like me but she has a lot of her mother Arrosa’s Basque features: olive skin, deep-set brown eyes, and large lips, which frame a mouth that can open wide enough, it seems, to hold a small melon.

I remembered the first time I saw Arrosa, more than thirty years ago now, at the old Depot Café in Mill Valley. I was a student at College of Marin and she an au pair for a wealthy family in the hills, dressed like an American kid, on her day off. She smiled at me first, but when I smiled back she became coy. I felt proud of my persistence in getting her phone number, with complete instructions on when I could call and when not.

“They didn’t even have any Shel Silverstein poems on the karaoke machine,” Sally blurted. She faced Pina and explained: “It was kind of like an AA meeting—everybody got a few minutes to either recite a poem or read one from the karaoke dealie projected on a screen.”

I wondered if Sally had her own experience with AA meetings or only knew about them from the movies.

“I always thought that the people who recited poems from memory were superior,” she continued, “like deacons of the church.”

“Like your dad?” Pina asked.

“Yeah, he was always wailing some long-ass Yeats poem.”

“I’ll never forget the day you stood up and recited that Shel Silverstein poem. How old were you when you did that?”

“Eleven.”

“I was so proud of you.”

Sally’s expression turned solemn and then she stood from her chair in the corner of the deck, raised her head high and recited:

 

The voice
By Shel Silvertesin

There is a voice inside you
That whispers all day long.
“I feel this is right for me.”
“I know that this is wrong.”
No teacher, preacher, parent, friend
Or wise man can decide
What’s right for you—just listen to the voice
That speaks inside.

 

“Remember? Everybody in the café applauded after you recited that.”

“Yeah, and that’s when I got bashful. I didn’t think people in a church were supposed to clap.”

“It wasn’t a real church, Sally.”

“That’s not what you told me at the time.”

It took until midnight for Sally to tell us why she arrived, unannounced, at our door. There was only the smallest hint of smoke in the air, but it had finally turned cool. Pina and I put on another layer but Sally seemed impervious to the chill. I told her that I could set up a futon for her in the second bedroom. “I can bring Roscoe out to the living room in his cage.”

“Doesn’t he sleep through the night?” Sally asked.

“Yes, but he wakes up early and starts yammering.”

“I wake early, too. I’ll yammer with him.”

I couldn’t keep from laughing. Sally didn’t know what she was in for.

“Thank you guys for your graciousness,” she said. “I mean, for not bugging me about what I’m doing here and just letting me hang out.”

Sally took a moment to relight what was left of her joint.

After offering Pina a light, which she declined, Sally inhaled deeply and, instead of exhaling through her nostrils, used her wide lips to blow outsized smoke rings.

“So, Alger isn’t on a trip; he left me for this bitch Gail who runs the cannabis facility where I used to work and where he still works. I stopped going in April. I didn’t think it was safe. A lot of the crew seemed dubious to me. Nobody was wearing a mask. I didn’t like Alger coming home from work, maybe getting us both sick. Our place is small. I told him to stay somewhere else and that’s what he did. It’s been a long time now. He even took our dog, Skipper.”

I caught her eye. “Sal, I’m so sorry. You never tell me what’s going on with you.”

“I am now.”

That shut me up, and Sally was quiet for a moment. She stood and walked to the edge of the deck, looking out at the row of Osage orange trees, and then turned back.

“So what have you been doing all this time, Sally?”

“Living off the money you put in my account and getting high. Asking myself existential questions that I have no answers for. I knew I had to get out of there but I was paralyzed. I should have called you, dad. I’m not sure what I’m doing here, but I had to go somewhere. ” Sally sniffled once, but she did not cry; the joint still burned between her fingers. “Alger and I had been fighting for a long time. I couldn’t stand the isolation any more. He said I was just a big city girl and that you couldn’t take the city out of the girl. I don’t know about that. I think there is a lot of daylight between the city and the wilderness.

“On the Lost Coast you are so many miles away from everything but the pot farms and the ocean. So, staying all those months, I figured I’d either be cured of loneliness or die of it. But, of course, neither happened. I drove away just as lonely as ever, but definitely alive.”

“I’m glad you came here, Sal.” I wanted to hug her, to hold her close, but I knew better.

Sally snuffed out her joint. I watched her bite her lower lip, but I turned away before she started sobbing. It looked like a flood coming. As a young girl, Sally cried forever and then at around age ten, shortly after her mother left, she shut off the valve and stopped crying altogether. I can’t remember seeing her cry since.

Now her tears became contagious. This wasn’t the kind of contagion I was worried about. I rubbed my eyes and gazed over at Pina, who smiled back at me, sniffling.

CHAPTER TWO – I LOVE SA-SA MONA

(c) Chester Arnold, 2020

On Monday, Charlie and I took the morning off and headed to the ocean. The heat in Sonoma has been brutal, with the addition of something we rarely have: high humidity. We saw the pulses of dry lightening and heard thunder, the night before. The little bit it rained didn’t correspond with the lightening strikes, so numerous fires broke out.

We studied the skies as we approached Muir Beach on Monday. To our north, a stark black swath of sky was divided, by a line as hard as the horizon, from the mottled overcast sky above us. We guessed we were in the clear and lugged our blanket and cooler, filled with enough picnic fare for a big clan, onto the beach. We saw distant lightening, but according to the forecast the skies were due to clear in the next hour. Almost as soon as we reached the beach, the edge of the black cloud spat rain and the wind went dervish with the sand, blasting our bare legs. Families packed up furiously and we all dashed back to the parking lot like the end of the world was upon us. Defeated, Charlie and I retreated to a tiny beach he knew in ritzy Belvedere, Paradise Cove—right across the bay from San Quentin, where half the prisoners have tested positive for Covid, a fact I couldn’t get out of my head as we had our picnic on the beach. I must have appeared abstracted as I ate my egg salad sandwich, because Charlie asked me what was going on. When I explained that my head was filled with prisoners, Charlie said, “Maybe they’ll let the healthy ones out to fight fires for a dollar an hour.”

The edge of the black cloud spat rain and the wind

           went dervish with the sand, blasting our bare legs.

(c) Chester Arnold, 2020

Later, we swam; the water wasn’t too cold but it felt clammy, as the bay usually does. The day’s saving grace was the three-dozen Hog Island oysters that we picked up at Larkspur Landing, on the drive home. They were the sweetest I’ve had in a long time. What a bounty, heaped on an ancient Corona platter, with a fine mignonette that Charlie made, with sliced shallots soaked in champagne vinegar.

This morning the smoke in the air is bad, with a dusting of ash on the deck. We’re getting alerts of evacuations, a long distance from here, but it’s just beginning. Rolling blackouts are threatened, but we haven’t seen any yet. There are fires burning in Vacaville. Interstate 80 is closed between Vacaville and Fairfield. A huge ring of fire surrounds Lake Berryessa. The entire city of Healdsburg is ready to evacuate. From there, it burns north of the Russian River into West County, and nearly to the ocean.

We closed everything up last night to keep the bad air out. Charlie’s even thinking about turning on the old air conditioner. I told him I don’t mind the heat, but I think he’s worried about his parrot.

“Put a damp towel over his cage,” I suggested, “That’s how McTeague protected his canary when he was on the lam in Death Valley.”

“How did that turn out?” Charlie asked, knowing full well that both McTeague and the canary perished.

“Hey, this isn’t exactly Death Valley,” which was in the news last week for hitting a temperature of 130.

A little before noon I saw Charlie walk into the parrot room with a wet towel.

 

I had my first client via Zoom today: Aubrey Kincaid, a prodigious stutterer in his mid thirties. Aubrey wore a well-pressed Oxford cloth shirt for the occasion. I kept things simple in a sleeveless linen dress, with a red onyx pendant that Charlie gave me the night I moved in.

For some reason, I waved at my client. “How are you, Aubrey?”

“Good. Good,” he said, nodding.

“It’s nice seeing you. What a lovely shirt.”

Aubrey took an audible sniff of the air. “I just iron-ironed it. Sooooo,” he said, stretching the word out, a trick I taught him for gathering his composure, “I have-have been doing my exercises.”

“I can tell.” It was true. Aubrey spoke with more fluency than I remember. In the past he stammered over nearly every word and his head-jerks, which often accompanied his speech delays, had disappeared.

Aubrey worked as an accountant at a firm in Corte Madera and had gone through a dark period, losing clients he attributed to his stuttering. That’s why he’d started therapy in the first place, about six months before the pandemic hit. From what Aubrey told me, he’d been as traumatized by his childhood speech therapy as by the stuttering itself, so I took a very relaxed conversational approach to our sessions, mixing in a light exercise or two. I’d gotten Aubrey in the habit of reading aloud to himself everyday, and also exaggerating the head jerks that had become part of his stuttering routine; full awareness is the best path to elimination.

My goal for the first session was to have an easy conversation with Aubrey. That would allow me to do a proper evaluation after all the time’s that’s elapsed.

It delighted me that Aubrey kicked off the conversation. “Soooo, what’s new with you, Pa-pina?”

Aubrey had never managed to pronounce my name without some sort of a hitch and this time a guttural grunt followed his flub.

I carried on without pause. “I moved to Sonoma,” I said.

“I love Sa-sa-mona,” he said, leaving the damaged name alone, as I’d counseled, and continued: “I really like the town square. Have you been to The Girl and the Fig?” Aubrey beamed after saying so much without a problem.

“Yes, yes. It’s one of my favorite spots in town.”

“Me too. Soooo, Pa-pina, you look fine.”

Nice as it was to hear that I looked fine, Aubrey’s comment was inappropriate. I wondered if messing up my name had led him somewhere he hadn’t meant to go. In any case, after his head jerked hard right for the first time during our conversation, he carried on as if nothing odd had happened, which is pretty much the fate of a life-long stutterer—carrying on as well as one can.

Soooo, Pa-pina, you look fine.”

Nice as it was to hear that I looked fine,

Aubrey’s comment was inappropriate.

“I went out on a date,” he said.

“Oh, good.”

“It was kind of a disaster.”

“I’m sorry.”

“It wasn’t so much the sta-stutter-stuttering. I could deal with that. We met for coffee at an outside café. The young lady didn’t look like her photo. She was fa-fat. I, you know, I didn’t want to be rude, but I couldn’t think of any-any-anything to say.”

“But you hung in there.”

“Yep. I hung in there.” I could tell that Aubrey was studying his own reflection, mugging a bit for the camera.

“Good for you, Aubrey.”

“I also went to a Ba-ba-black Lives Matter protest in the city. Guess what,” he said and then chuckled. “My-my sign didn’t stutter.”

“What did it say?”

“No-no justice, no peace. I’m-I’m try-trying to get in touch with my-my privilege.”

“That’s great, Aubrey. Me too.”

He nodded his head proudly. “Except-cept, I don’t-don’t feel that privileged.”     Aubrey then turned quiet. I could see the old shame spilling over him.

I carried on much of rest of the conversation, asking Aubrey about his job and his twin sisters who he’s worked hard to forgive after they teased him relentlessly throughout his stuttering childhood.

Aubrey chimed in with short answers and we agreed to Zoom the following Thursday.

 

I can’t get enough of Charlie lately. When I say that to myself, I think first of Charlie’s body and then of his soul. They both satisfy me. Which says a fuck of a lot. The funny thing is I’d rather not see Charlie much during the day. I’m at my desk trying to figure out how many clients I can work with under the circumstances. During the long pandemic months while I resisted the opportunity to work from a distance, I reinvented myself. I truly believe that. The hours of solitude, which frightened me at first, have now become a necessary feature of my daily life. I knew that moving in with Charlie would compromise my solitude to a degree, but I decided the trade-off was worth it.

During the recent hot days Charlie has come in to gawk at me, plotzed half naked in the executive swivel chair I commandeered from him. I don’t mind seeing him for a flash or having a quick lunch with him, but I prefer to save him until later, for love and play. We are still so new with each other that it’s premature to claim that familiarity breeds contempt, but perhaps I fear that if we are not rigorous about maintaining some distance contempt will develop.

I’m still puzzled that I could fall for a man who spends the bulk of his day training a parrot. I have no idea what he’s after, but he carries on like a mad scientist. He tries to keep the extent of his Roscoe training from me, claiming he’s in a rut, working on dead-end animation projects. I know better. Anyway, Charlie isn’t a dead-end kind of a guy. He has what’s described as the happiness gene; the dude is bubbling over with serotonin. It cheers me to be with a man, who’s neither cynical nor sarcastic, features of my nature that I’ve, at least temporarily, put on hold, but which thrived in the years I spent with my faux husband Vince. Does my choice of Charlie mean that I’ve evolved or does it portend an inevitable clash of natures that will destroy us? I’m inclined to believe the latter, but there’s no sense in counting my dead chickens before they croak.

 

I’m still puzzled that I could fall for a man

    who spends the bulk of his day training a parrot.

The last two nights Charlie persuaded me to watch the Democratic convention. He gets tears in his eyes during all the human-interest stories, and when Obama made his marvelous speech the night before, Charlie clutched my hand. Last night the brave speech by the stuttering boy who met Joe Biden brought me to tears. I hesitate to believe this, but I think Charlie’s humanity is rubbing off on me.

One of the convention commentators mentioned that to help himself as a childhood stutterer, Biden read poems by W. B. Yeats.

“That’s the coolest thing I’ve ever heard about Biden—the dude stuttered his way through Yeats poems.”

“Have you ever used Yeats with your stutterers?” Charlie asked

“Not yet.” Then Charlie surprised me by reciting the first stanza of “The Second Coming”:

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

Hearing Charlie recite the lines moved me. “How did you memorize that?” I asked, foolishly.

“Oh, I’ve memorized a lot of poems. This one seems appallingly on point for the moment. It was written in 1919 at the end of World War I.”

“And, God damn,” I said, “I don’t know how a stutterer could get through that poem. Every other word is a trigger. Turning, widening anarchy, conviction, passionate.”

And then Charlie, who does not stutter, recited the entire poem not, as Vince does, with a lofty self-consciousness, but as a common man who wants to travel with the words and their meaning down the crooked road of his life.

CHAPTER ONE – SHIVER MY TIMBERS

I feel I’ve had no choice in the matter. Consequently, I’ve kept most of my work with Roscoe a secret from Pina. I got the feeling early that a little bit of the parrot would go a long way for her. She found the bird tedious and once asked whether my obsession with teaching Roscoe every word in the God damn Webster’s Dictionary, was going to drive me mad.

It could, I allowed, it certainly could.

But I don’t really care about the size of Roscoe’s vocabulary. He’s mastered thousands of words and scores of sentences. I do my best to keep his achievements under wraps. I’m actually focused on how to teach the parrot to think. Like everyone else, I doubted the possibility until I discovered how deftly Roscoe followed scripts and constructed unique parallels. I keep reminding myself that a bird is not a computer. Even now I’m not sure that it’s actually thinking that Roscoe does. The circuits of his small brain respond to complex sequencing as if he were wired for it. Maybe it’s nothing more than rote learning taken to a new level of sophistication.

Roscoe (c) Chester Arnold, 2020

Read any manual about training a parrot to talk and it will tell you not to overdo it. Give the bird a command or two and then offer a treat. Never exceed a few minutes a day. You don’t want your parrot to lose interest, nor do you want to turn him into a rebel. It so happens that Roscoe has a very long attention span; at times it seems to exceed mine. This is a creature that relishes the training. When I asked him recently, after an hours-long session, whether he’d had enough, he turned the question back on me and it grew a second query: “Have you had enough, Charlie? Do you need a treat, Charlie?”

Once when I said that I was going off to make a martini,” he intoned in his low crackling voice, “In that case, shiver my timbers, I’ll have a thimble of Barbados rum, Charlie.”

After repeating that sentence a half dozen times: In that case, shiver my timbers, I’ll have a thimble of Barbados rum, I discovered that I’d become the parrot.

Roscoe had constructed a charming line of poetry, rich in assonance. I realized the line possessed what writers fresh from MFA programs call voice. How was this possible?

After my sixth repetition, Roscoe praised me: “That’s very good, Charlie. You’re making genuine progress.”

I have no memory of teaching Roscoe the rum sentence. Sad to say, I’m not creative enough to coin a line like that. No, it was the product of Roscoe’s extensive vocabulary, intuitive language-sequencing skills, the countless hours of tapes I play for him, and, yes, I’ll say it, his uncanny grasp of logic. But how to account for a parrot who speaks naturally in the language of poetry?

Early on, as a lark, I gave Roscoe a taste of several kinds of alcohol. Scotch, I told him, was sipped by gentlemen and ladies, very slowly. He followed my cue, nibbling daintily at the drink. Before offering him his first thimble of rum, I explained that pirates served their parrots rum, at least in storybooks. His response unnerved me— “Are you a pirate, Charlie?” “Charlie,” the parrot said: “Is this a storybook?”

“Are you a pirate, Charlie?”

I pondered that.

“Charlie,” the parrot asked:

“Is this a storybook?”

Some days during quiet time, when I’m sitting at my desk, I hear Roscoe mumbling in his cage. He can’t always keep silent. His brain is in overdrive; he’s busy wrestling with phrases, experimenting with emphasis and tone: The nerve of him. Will you get a load of that? It’s first come, first served around here, Bub.

The other day I put some music on for Roscoe, the long movement of John Adams’ Saxophone Concerto, which ranges from Animato, Moderato, Tranquillo to Suave. I watched Roscoe intently listening. He started to mouth the music, chewing along with the sixteenth notes, ghost-calling angular intervals, and, during a brief tuneful French horn solo in the Tranquillo section, reciting musical terms that he picked up during weekly foreign language drills. I was impressed with the clarity of his pronunciation, but also by the fitting character he gave to the terms. Andante spilled slowly, even delicately, out of his mouth, while vivace soared into lively leaps through the syllables. When I introduced the term scherzo, I pointed out that it meant joke in Italian. He pronounced it during the Adams concerto in a lilting nasal burst, tagging on a brief chuckle for a coda.

Weeks before Pina moved in, even before she told me, to my delight, that she would, I had the second bedroom of the condo, soundproofed. That‘s where Roscoe trains and listens to the recordings and scripts I play for him. I suppose I’m afraid that if Pina discovered how deeply I’m involved with Roscoe’s training, and the degree of his prowess with language and cognitive skills, she’d flee in horror. Nobody wants to live in a house with Dr. Frankenstein. Some day Pina will discover the extent of Roscoe’s skills and what I am grooming him for, but until then my relationship with the African grey remains just another odd hobby pursued by a middle-aged man during the pandemic.

 

Because I am a masochist, I tuned in yesterday afternoon to Trump’s news conference, and then a delightful moment surfaced. A White House reporter, named S. V. Dáte from the Huffington Post, who looked like a seasoned diplomat, asked, in a measured matter-of-fact manner: “Mr. President, after three and a half years, do you regret at all, all the lying you’ve done to the American people?”

Trump looked like a deer in the headlights. He couldn’t concoct a fresh lie quickly enough and, after an awkward pause, he turned from S. V. Dáte and called on another reporter.

Unfortunately, I am alone in the house with all the political news. Pina has declared a moratorium on all things tied to the coming election as well as everything Trump, so I either take my news in the soundproof room or listen out front with headphones. I’ve yet to introduce the political world to Roscoe, although that will clearly play a big part in his future.

Pina and I haven’t even spoken about Biden’s selection of Kamala Harris, but I have the sense that she got the word, most likely from her ex, Vince, with whom she speaks frequently. She makes a point of letting me know after she’s conversed with Vince, an effort to show me that she’s not being duplicitous. I’m surprised she thinks that’s necessary. If I’m within earshot, I can tell when Vince calls because Pina’s assigned him a specific ringtone: a barking dog. I don’t know what to make of her devotion to the recovering addict. Perhaps it’s simple jealousy on my part, and yet it’s occurred to me that her concern for Vince may represent a form of penance for moving in with me. My jealousy and Pina’s feelings of guilt, if that’s what they are, are not mutually exclusive.

In one of her recent conversations with Vince I noticed a broad smile crest on Pina’s face. Then I heard her say, “She was the one I was hoping for.” I find it curious that Pina hasn’t invoked her moratorium about Trump and the election with Vince.

 

This afternoon it reached 105 degrees in Sonoma. I was a little disappointed because the forecast called for 106 and I’m fond of extremes. I refuse to turn on the air conditioner—I don’t like the artificial air or the waste of energy—and Pina seems to thrive in the heat. I spent the whole day in shorts without a shirt and Pina did the same. I made every excuse I could to go into the bedroom, where she keeps her office, just to gaze at her beautiful breasts, until finally she rose from her desk chair and pressed up against me.

“You know what the heat does to me?” she said.

Dumb as I am, I didn’t have a clue.

“It makes me horny. How about you, Charlie?”

“Same with me, especially when I’m around you.”

“I don’t know what it is; it just gets all my juices going. Hmm, you smell so good, Charlie.”

Soon enough we stripped off each other’s shorts and rolled around on the sheets, making hot sweaty love.

Afterwards, we both lay on our backs, panting in a damp heap, Pina asked: “Have you always been such a magnificent lover, Charlie?”

That’s not the kind of question my ex asked.

     “Have you always been

      such a magnificent lover, Charlie?”

     That’s not the kind of question my ex asked.

“This is where we’re supposed to smoke cigarettes,” I said, “like we’re in a French flick.”

“I have a joint rolled,” Pina said, and rose from the bed in a burst. I watched her slender body slice through the space with the assurance of somebody fully at home in her skin.

When Pina returned, she not only brought the joint but also a small basket of plump figs, the first of the season. “Let’s save these until after we smoke.”

She lit the joint with my brushed brass Zippo and we passed the doobie back and forth until we’d both smoked too much of it.

“So what’s this movie called?” Pina asked, busting into a devilish laugh.

I pondered that a moment. “Figs Without Leaves?” I said, finally, rather pleased with the title. I took hold of a fig but instead of biting into it, I suckled one of Pina’s breasts. Coming up for air, I affected a posh British accent: “I know that we are in Eden, however, I’m not sure which is the forbidden fruit.”

“Silly boy,” she said, “nothing is forbidden.”

CHAPTER THIRTY

THE HUMANS

 

 

It’s Saturday morning and she and Charlie decide to walk to the square to have a look at what is open and to see if there’s much tourist frenzy. Along the way they stroll past the Clydesdale farm where the man from yesterday with the feed cap, sits high in his carriage, with the collie on his lap, and drives two horses in broad circles around the dry pasture, raising clouds of dust.

They pause at the magnificent cactus in front of the mission. It’s an ageless edifice of paddles and thorns filled with tempting, unimaginable fruits. On one of her first times with Vince in Sonoma, he tried to pluck out a pear for her. This after telling a cautionary tale about people he’d seen mauled by the notorious cactus for tempting its dangers. Vince caught a few needles in his right hand and she thought she’d have to come to the aid of the old emergency room doctor, but he turned out to be good with both hands. After he got out the thorns he kept licking his fingers and lamented that he didn’t even get a fruit for her. She thanked Vince for the noble gesture, just as she realized that his hubris knew no bounds. Pina was the fruit that he really wanted to pluck; she wonders if she’s been more dangerous for him than the cactus.

At 10:30 in the morning there are plenty of tourists on the square, many do not wear face coverings. She and Charlie jut out onto the street to avoid these culprits. The other day Charlie suggested that she might want to chill a bit about people not wearing masks. “Au contraire,” she said, baring her teeth at him, “I want to get tee shirts printed that read: ARE YOU TOO REPUBLICAN TO WEAR A MASK?

The Swiss Hotel now has tables running up the alley beside it. She thinks about how much Vince loved to sit out front of the Swiss, gorging himself on the fresh bread and hot-peppered olive oil before his bowl of mussels and clams arrived. She doubts that she’ll ever sit at a table here with him again.

The Girl and the Fig has tables running up the side street parallel to their garden seating. The only inside place on the square that she misses is the gorgeous polished oak bar at the Fig.

They cross over to the park to avoid a line of brunchers weaving its way from the door of the Sunflower Café. Charlie leads her to the bench at the duck pond, where she approached him, four months ago now.

“So this is the fateful spot,” she says.
“Little did you know what you were getting into.”

She wants to tell him that she did know, although that would be a lie.

Charlie takes off his mask. “I love you, Pina.” Now he peels off her mask and kisses her.

 

A smart person, she thinks, would not turn on the car radio but stay attuned to the natural beauty around her, as she drives to the city; she flicks on the radio. There’s more talk about last night’s pardon of Roger Stone; news about the White House sending out anonymous opposition research against the administration’s leading infectious disease specialist, Dr. Fauci, because he’s seen as making Trump look bad. Trump wore a large black mask in public for the first time today. Pina figures he’s always wanted to wear blackface. If Florida were a country, the newscaster says, it would be rated #4 in the world in the number of Coronavirus cases, behind the U.S., India, and Brazil. Also, Florida is registering a new positive case every five and a half seconds. And yet, Disney World in Orlando is opening today. With that note of lunacy, Pina switches off the radio. A high silky swath of fog hangs over Sausalito, but the pylons of the Golden Gate Bridge stand clear. Across the belly of water, the city gleams.

 

Majestic Dolores Park, with its terraced hillside, its palm trees, and glittering view of the downtown skyline, was their local park. She and Vince often came over on Sundays to sun themselves, read The Times, and listen to the conga players. Now the grassy hillside and flats have been painted with huge white social distancing circles, most of them occupied. She sees the park from 20th street, the top, at first. The repetition of circles, with humans enclosed, is otherworldly. She starts to count the circles but there are too many. It all seems somehow lunar to her or like the aerial view of potential bombsites. The obedience of all these humans sitting in ones and twos and threes within their satellites is striking; humans, the most flawed of animals, managing to kill ourselves through arrogance and folly.

She finds a spot near the top of the hill with two open circles. She sits in one and kicks off her espadrilles to put in the other circle. Hard to know what the etiquette is on saving circles. Vince will know to meet her up top because it’s where they always perched in the Park. She hasn’t made up her mind what she’ll tell him. Her life these last four months, like most everybody’s, has been an improvisation so there’s little need to change it now.

Now she sees Vince striding up the hill toward her. He’s wearing his maize colored linen coat and a pair of khakis, looking tall and put-together, no slouch in his step.

“Pina,” he calls, a big grin on his face.
“Hey, Vince.” She lifts her shoes out of the neighboring circle.

Despite standing tall and grooming himself, he’s winded when he gets to the top of the hill, and looks played out.

Pina indicates the empty circle.

“You want me to sit in my own? I’ve just been tested.”
“But I haven’t.”
“God’s it’s weird. I can’t even touch you.”
“No.”

Vince, still standing, scans the park a moment. “What the fuck kind of alternative world has this become? It’s like some shit out of Dante.”
The Inferno only has nine circles.”
“How do you know that, Pina?”
“You told me once, and I even remember what they are. Aren’t you going to sit?”

She looks away as Vince goes through painful contortions to seat himself in his circle. He lands with a thud.

“Hey, I’m alive. Getting healthy.”
“I like your spirit,” she says, although it seems to her that he’s hardly even faking it. “The first circle is Limbo.”
“Yes. That’s the spot for virtuous pagans.”
“Is that how you see yourself, Vince?”
He stretches out a leg. “Certainly a pagan, but scant on the virtues. I think I’m running a deficit on the account.”

“Be kind to yourself, mister.” She smiles at him and forces him to smile back. “You need to be kind to yourself. We all need to be kind to ourselves to get through this.” Of course, she and Vince have very different things to get through, but the advice is universally apt. Pina surprises herself with her bit about kindness. Somehow she’s internalized Sylvie’s words and become an evangelist for the cause. Vince was never about kindness; she knew that from the start, just as she recognized that Vince’s self-absorption would prevent him from really caring about her. Essential to their tacit contract was that they look out for themselves, which is what makes it so easy to walk away from any contract that’s left.

Vince rests his chin on his wrist. The man’s weary. Existentially weary. Suicide weary. Sylvie never had that look. She wonders if the process of recovery and self-reflection, at this late date, has somehow taken more from Vince than it’s given him. Perhaps he’s dug deep enough to hit a reservoir of shame and left himself to wallow in it.

She’s tempted to run through the other eight circles of hell, to make Vince laugh and hear his commentary. She knows them better than she knows the Ten Commandments. After Limbo come Lust, Gluttony, Greed, Anger, Heresy, Violence, Fraud and, finally, Treachery. Taken together, they sound like the attributes of Trump’s resume. Which circle will she land in? Of course, she’d prefer Limbo; she can aspire to being a virtuous pagan.

She smiles again at Vince, whose face is abstracted. For once he is at a loss for words. She owes him something, surely, but she’s having trouble making contact with the man he is now, an addict, perhaps for far longer than she knew. “Are you still writing poems, Vince?”

He shakes his head. “I need to get back to that.”
“Are you okay?”
“Oh,” he says, and yawns for so long that the act might encompass a lifetime of weariness. “Pardon me. I guess you could say that I’m feeling a bit unmoored. Bernard brought me by the house. It’s in nice shape now.”
“How long will you stay in the halfway house?”
“It’s called an SLE, a sober living environment. How long will I stay? That’s to be determined. I can’t imagine staying very long in a house, and sharing a room with two others, when I have a two point five million dollar house waiting for me.”

He can’t imagine staying clean for long either, she thinks. And why does he find it necessary to put a price tag on his house?

“You’re not coming back, are you, Pina?”
“No.” She offers him a taut, closed-lip smile.
“I figured you’d had it with me. I was hoping it could be different, that you would wait for me.”
“Wait for what?”
“My recovery.”
“You’ll need to spend the rest of your life on your recovery. I wish you luck. I really do, Vince.” There’s no need to say anymore. If her decision is selfish, then it’s selfish. It is also the right decision.
Vince’s eyes have grown moist. “We had some good times, Pina.”
“Yes, we did.” She’s a little surprised that he’s giving up so easily, but this may be the new Vince.
“You can stay in Sonoma until you sort out what you’re going to do.”
“That’s kind of you, Vince. I’m going to move in with Charlie.”
“Charlie,” he repeats, before sparking a short laugh. “He’s a nice guy,” Vince says, with a bit of snark in his voice.

“Yes, he is,” she says, and looks ahead at the humans in circles, those gathered in twos and threes sharing intimacies, the solo-circled, like she and Vince, solitary on their islands, reading and snoozing, and having conversations with themselves.

Gradually, Pina lifts her eyes. In the foreground, she sees the tiled-roofed rectangle of Mission High School, with its quirky Spanish Baroque tower. Beyond it, although invisible from her vantage, are the countless tents of the homeless, an architecture of ruin spilling to the eastern edge, where the sun shines on empty office towers—the majestic city and the civilization, tottering.

 

—The End—

March 14 – July 15, 2020

CHAPTER TWENTY-NINE

THE CLYDESDALES

 

Three afternoons after they discovered Sylvie’s body, a pair of Clydesdales pulls a wagon, shiny black enamel with spokes and wheels painted bright white, up East Second Street. Having heard hooves striking the pavement down the street, she and Charlie spring out of bed and hurry to the edge of the deck to watch the horses and wagon pass. The late afternoon sun shines on the brown flanks of the animals. It is a placid scene. Nobody is in a hurry. The enormous strength of these behemoths is fully restrained, and the clack of hooves might be percussion for a slow movement of Aaron Copeland’s “Appalachian Spring.” She can’t resist thinking of these animals as noble even though they are probably dumb as beans.

Now Pina thinks of photographs she’s seen of ceremonial hearses, among them images of President Kennedy’s funeral procession. Didn’t horses lead the open carriage that held his coffin, draped in an American flag? The two chattering men sitting atop this wagon, one in a feed cap holding the reins, the other sitting shotgun in a cowboy hat, with a collie on his lap, dispel any sense of the funereal. This is Norman Rockwell rolling up East Second Street.

She and Charlie have spent most of the last three days in bed. After Sylvie’s death, Pina wanted to go on a retreat, but when you can’t go anywhere, and you’ve already withdrawn from the world, bed seemed like the only viable option. At first she thought Charlie was simply humoring her, but from late in the first afternoon, when she turned him from his stomach to his back, explaining that she didn’t want him to end up with bedsores, and then performing epic fellatio on him, he’s been all in. It’s true, they’ve made love more often in the last couple of days than she and Vince did in the last months they lived together. She’s not sure what kind of medications Charlie takes, nor does she care, but he is one hell of a tiger.

The wide-ranging conversations they’ve had have been even more surprising than the prodigious lovemaking. At first she was reminded of her early days with Marco, when they seemed to have discovered every hidden corner of each other during their nightlong talking jags. With Charlie, who is the least defensive man she’s ever known, no subject is forbidden. Once he got going about his ex, Cynthia, who left him for the jazz drummer, he disclosed so much about their intimacies, or lack thereof, that Pina felt embarrassed for him, although he didn’t seem self-conscious in the least. Whatever embarrassment there was belonged to her.

“The long and short of it is that all Cynthia wanted to do,” he said, putting a wrap to the subject, at least for the time being, “was party.”
Pina smirked. “Sounds like me.”
“The difference is huge, Pina, because you party with a soul.”

After she got him to promise to never again use the word party as a verb, she asked him to describe her soul, as he perceived it. His explanation was not only endearing, but it went on for hours, on both sides of their naps.

During their three days in bed, Charlie only got up to use the bathroom and look after Roscoe’s feed and water. In addition to her visits to the bathroom, Pina prepared their simple meals, fried eggs and toast, pasta with vegetables and parmesan, and a niçoise salad, all of which they ate together in bed.

The real breakthrough for Pina came from talking about Marco. Charlie wasn’t much interested in hearing about Vince. He knew Vince, described him as a moving target, and said that the last thing he wanted to do was put any pressure on her to make decisions about Vince. But Marco was a phantom, an abstraction, is what he said. “I wouldn’t know where to begin with an animation of him.”

That’s where they began, with Marco in his body. How he stepped in the world.

“Marco was short,” she told Charlie, “but he was proud of his body.”
“Good balance?”
“Yes, he was a terrific skater.” She could see that Charlie was already imagining his animation, so she offered him more: “When he walked he was quiet. Quietest walker you’ve ever seen, Charlie.”
“So was he devious?”

“That’s a question for later,” she said, but talked for so long about what made Marco’s body quiet that the spill of her language, across the sheets, bled into Marco’s personality and she explained, as much to herself as to Charlie, that Marco’s soft step was present in his affect, and she found herself revealing that, with Marco, it was easy to confuse his silence with virtue, “not that he was without virtue,” she asserted, clinging, vaguely still, to her myth of Marco’s unimpeachable goodness.

When Charlie asked how Marco’s quietness affected her personality, she began to cry, but did so only briefly, recalling how she sometimes felt like a brash boor beside Marco and had trained herself to be less emotional. “Somehow I decided that all the defects were mine. I guess it kind of makes sense that after Marco I ended up with a guy like Vince, who can’t be quiet for a moment and is brimming with defects.”

Later, when she addressed Charlie’s initial question, she cried again. “If Marco was devious,” she said, “it was in making it seem that something was going on when there wasn’t. I didn’t hear John Prine’s sweet song ‘Hello in There’ until later, but that’s the kind of thing she wanted to say to Marco at times: ‘Hello in there. Is anybody home?’ Sadly, Marco embodied Gertrude Stein’s long ago description of Oakland: ‘There was no there there.’ He wanted a simple life with very little conflict. His manner came across as enlightenment while I ended up feeling like a complicated mess. And when Marco got sick and never complained he became saintly in my mind, and that’s the Marco I’ve lived with all these years.”

“And so now,” Charlie said, after a long silence, “you’ll probably have to mourn your ideal.”

“Yes,” she said and became weepy again before falling into a long afternoon snooze.

By this afternoon, when they saw the Clydesdales pass, she and Charlie had begun to tire of being in bed, but they went back anyway. Charlie brought his large laptop and they started to watch “Hamilton.” Sadness swept over Pina, but she felt as if she’d been freed of something. Perhaps she was the only person in America to not make much contact with “Hamilton.” And yet, it seemed consequential when she and Charlie began singing, “No one else was in the room where it happened.” She lay in Charlie’s arms and smiled at him. She was so glad to have let him into the room where it happened.

 

A call from Vince comes not long after they finish their dinner, a tasty roast chicken with asparagus and Basmati rice. She left Charlie in the kitchen with the dishes and walked out onto Second Street East in the direction of the cemetery.

After quickly dispensing with pleasantries, Vince asked if she could meet him tomorrow in the city. Bernard was picking him up tomorrow—his month at the facility in Nicasio was coming to an end and he was supposed to move into a sober living environment—a halfway house, of sorts, that they arranged for him in the Mission.

“I only have a short window of time, a couple of hours, before I’m due at the house,” he said, his voice sober, free of its cunning lilt. “And just so you know, I was just tested again for Covid and I’m negative.”

Pina agrees to meet Vince at Dolores Park tomorrow at two o’clock, and walks up into the cemetery. The light is beginning to go out of the sky. It is a Friday night and she can hear a group of rollicking teenagers at the top of the cemetery, where they go to drink beer. The living and the dead. After passing the split gravestone of Thomas Thornton Seawall, which she can barely make out in the dusk light, she thinks more of Marco and Sylvie than of Charlie and Vince. A sweet impression of Andre, Sylvie’s son, lingers. Clearly, he was in grief as he waited with Pina for the county morgue to come pick up his mother, but the way he grasped Pina’s hand in both of his, and thanked her for what she’d done for Sylvie, moved her deeply.

 

Charlie is full of news when she gets back. Over their days in bed, she has steadfastly kept herself from the news, though she suspects that Charlie’s been sneaking looks on his laptop all along.

“Trump just pardoned his crony Roger Stone. They always do this shit on Friday night. Friday night massacre. His corruption knows no bounds.”

Pina doesn’t want to remember who Roger Stone is or what his crimes were, but no matter, Charlie quickly moves on to another outrage.

“He’s saying, against the advice of the health professionals, that if schools don’t reopen in the fall he’s taking back their federal money. He says, children don’t’ get sick anyway, which isn’t true, and what about the teachers and their families?”

Pina nods and hopes the news will end quickly.

“He bragged on Sean Hannity or some damn place about acing his cognitive test and you should see what Sarah Cooper did with that. I think it’s her best one yet.”

Pina sits beside Charlie on the sofa. Their streak of days in bed has officially ended. They watch Sarah Cooper’s “How to Cognitive” over and over, maybe a dozen times, until they are both repeating the words:

“Because he hasn’t taken any cognitive test cause he couldn’t pass one. I actually took one. Very recently when I . . . ah . . . when I was . . . when the radical left was saying, ‘Is he all there? Is he all there?’ And I proved I was all there because I aced it . . . I aced the test.” This is where Sarah pulls up the blank coloring book page of the donkey. “And he should take the same exact test, a very standard test. I took it . . . I took it at . . . Walter Reed . . . Medical Center. In front of doctors . . . and they were very surprised. They said, ‘that’s an unbelievable thing. Rarely does anybody do what you just did.” Now she shows the donkey fully scribbled over in a half dozen colors, as a one-year-old would do.

“You know,” Charlie says, after shutting his laptop. “Sarah Cooper has given us something of immeasurable value. Now when I hear his voice I see her face and I’m laughing.”
Pina slips into Charlie’s arms now. “Should we sleep out here tonight, just for a change?”
“Anything you want. By the way, I have a little question for you: Will you move in with me, Pina?”
“You’d have me?”
“Don’t answer a question with a question.”
“Do you think there’s room for me?”
“We’ll make room. I want you and all of your very complicated soul.”
“What will Roscoe say?”
“You’re still asking questions, Pina.”
“Don’t you think you should have a cognitive test, before we decide, Charlie?”

CHAPTER TWENTY-EIGHT

THE ANTS

 

Olga seems less interested in greeting Pina than in scoping out Vince’s condo. She takes herself on a little walking tour of the front room. Pina wants to tell her not to touch anything, that they need to keep their social distance, but instead she’s quiet, just like one of her clients, wondering why she invited her old friend up here in the first place.

Olga saunters onto the deck. The galvanized tub filled of basils and peppers takes her by surprise.

“Wow, Pina, is it your gardening?”
“I’d hardly call it gardening. I do best with minimalist efforts.”
“At least you know yourself, Pina.”
“That’s highly questionable.”

Olga bends over the rail to have a look. “Who has the lovely roses down here?”

“That’s Sylvie. We’re becoming friends, of sorts. She’s very smart, and can be comfortable like a good aunt. She actually reminds me of my mother sometimes. Pina brings her voice down to a measured breath. “She has surprisingly good ears for somebody her age. She gets a little testy sometimes but she gives very good advice.”

Olga laughs and Pina drops a finger over her lips to remind her friend to keep on the quiet side. “As I remember, “ Olga says in an exaggerated whisper that’s more like a hiss, “you don’t take people’s advice well. How could an old woman advise you? What kind of advice has she given you?”

“Nothing comes to mind off the top of my head.” In fact, after Sylvie proclaimed Charlie kind and relayed her mother’s advice about kind men, she asked Pina for a piece of advice. She thought it sweet, the way Sylvie asked: “Please, honey, tell me how to get rid of the ants in my living room. I’ve got a trail of them coming in from the yard. I keep shooting Parsley Plus at them, but it’s like the story of civilization, Pina, the dead are simply followed by the living.”

Pina suggests to Olga that they sit out on the deck where she’s positioned two chairs at appropriate distance. She whipped up a pitcher of margaritas in advance. Now she salts the rims of a couple tall glasses, fills them and floats lime slices.

“Do you want us to get sloshed, Pina?”
“Drink at your own risk, darling.”
“Do we have to whisper the whole time out here?”
“Don’t worry about it.”

They clink glasses. “Are we supposed to do that, Pina? Is that Covid safe?” Olga spills a little of her drink on her white peddle pushers as she brings the glass to her lips.

“God dog, Olga, if you’re spilling before you’ve even drunk any you’re in a bad way.”

Olga wrinkles her nose in response, and then takes a long careful sip.

“Olga, I’ve forgotten, have you been up here to the condo beside that time with Janice and Molly when everybody got super loaded on wine and Janice made us watch Porn Hub?”
“Don’t you remember, you and Vince had me up for a weekend a couple of years ago? I slept on the futon in the second bedroom.”

Pina forces a smile. Of course she remembers. Vince blasted jazz and quoted poetry all night; they all drank way too much. Vince became sloppy and lascivious. He wanted to go to bed with both of them. He practically shoved his tongue down Olga’s throat. It was hard to say how much Olga encouraged him, but she and Olga managed to hold Vince off, until he mixed himself a chemical cocktail that knocked him out. For all she knows, Vince snuck into the second bedroom in the middle of the night and fucked her.

Olga has cut her hair short since she last saw her. With her deep dimples and bright green eyes, she appears girlish, which is curious for a woman in her early fifties. But somehow it all goes along with Olga’s childish lisp. Pina used to tell her that she could help with the lisp, help her find another placement for her tongue and show her exercises that would reinforce it, but Olga always demurred. The lisp had become part of her personality. Some people thought it was cute.

“Wow, I like your hair, Olga,” she says, even though she’s not sure that she does.
“It’s one less thing that I have to care for. I’m really in this mode now of shedding everything I can. It’s like this weird trip I’m going through due to the Covid, because who knows when I might end up dead? I don’t want to leave a bunch of crap behind.”
“You really think about that, Olga?”
“Damn straight. I’m reminded of my mother warning me to change my underwear every day because a respectable girl doesn’t want to be found in dirty underwear if she dies in a crash. I used to think, who the fuck is going to check my underwear if I’m killed in a crash?”
“So, did you change it every day?” Pina asks.
“Yep, always did, always do. The great mother still has a lot of influence. You never met her did you, Pina? She also had a lisp. I think I come from a long line of lispers.” She laughs and flaunts her flawed sibilance with a sputter of s’s and z’s.
“Anyway, I’m like liquidating my shit right and left. Books, pots and pans I never use, chipped dishes, paintings I made when I was in grad school, even my giant coleus plant, which I’ve had since before my divorce with Robert. I got sick of looking at the motherfucker.”

Who, Pina wants to ask, the coleus or Robert? She remembers Robert, a tall, thin man with a prominent Adam’s apple. He was a financial analyst or an investment banker, some damn job that made a shitload of money. She never understood what Olga saw in him, except the money. Robert was a Libertarian, who’d get heated easily on a couple of drinks and rail on humorlessly about abolishing the IRS and eliminating the “welfare state.” Pina remembers sitting with Marco in Olga and Robert’s Russian Hill apartment during one of Robert’s performances. Olga was fairly deft at getting him to quiet down, but she remembers Marco, at the end of the evening as they walked up the street to their car, asking how Olga could stand her husband. She was married to Robert for nearly twenty years, and she’s lived years now on alimony and whatever she makes teaching yoga.

“Tell me something, Pina, if it’s not too personal. Do you ever wish you had children?”
“To bring into this world?”
“Never?”
“Only after Marco died. I wished I’d had a little Marco. How about you?”
“Yes, I think about it a lot. There’s no way I was going to get pregnant with Robert—end up with a little Libertarian running around. And after Robert my biological clock . . .”

Both Olga and Pina stand and stamp their feet in tempo with each other. “My biological clock is ticking like this,” they call in unison, doing their best to approximate Marisa Tomei’s Brooklyn brogue in “My Cousin Vinnie,” a film they watched together more than once, back in the day. Pina wonders how closely Sylvie is listening to their song and dance.

Seated again, Olga takes a long sip of her margarita and then lowers her head. “Here we are, two barren women in our fifties.”
“That’s how you feel, Olga, like a barren woman?”
“I wake up some mornings and feel very empty. It’s not the same for you, Pina. You have a man, two men.”

Pina has no response. She’s never thought of herself as being barren. It strikes her as a pejorative term along the lines of old maid. She made the choice not to have children. It wasn’t something that did or didn’t happen to her, but she doesn’t want to share her feelings about this with Olga. “That must be very difficult,” is all she manages to say.

Olga’s holds out her glass: “How about a refill, Pina?”

Pina fills her friend’s glass to the very top.

“What about you, aren’t you going to have another, Pina?”
“I’m trying to cut back.”
“Oh, for Christ’s sake. The world’s coming to an end and you’re on the wagon. So you made the pitcher of margaritas just to get me soused?”

 

After being introduced to Olga, it’s Roscoe that flirts with her rather than Charlie.

“Nice to meet you, Olga,” he yelps, his nasal voice, rising and falling dramatically. “Olga is a Russian name, isn’t it?”
“Oh my God,” Olga says. She’s more than a little tipsy and drops both her hands over her eyes. Olga peeks at Pina and whispers, “He doesn’t even have a lisp.”

Pina has gotten used to Roscoe’s new bursts of language. Charlie has developed ways of cuing the parrot and teaching him scripts and, now that she hears Roscoe every day, these phrases strike her as wooden and disembodied.

“Ask her again, Roscoe,” Charlie prompts.
“Again,” Roscoe repeats, his trained brain kicking into action. “Olga is a Russian name, isn’t it?”

Olga bursts into a loud spasm of bright laughter, which takes her a moment to corral. “It actually derives from the Old Norse,” she says, showing off her lisp.

Roscoe looks stumped. Norse is not a word he’s been programmed to respond to.

“Shall we take our leave of Roscoe and have some lunch now?” asks Charlie.
“Good idea,” Pina says. Her tolerance for the Roscoe project has waned over the last weeks.
After a hiccup and a spurt of laughter, Olga says, “Nice to meet you, Roscoe.”
“El gusto es mio,” Roscoe replies in a sing-songy tremolo.
Charlie smiles at his parrot before turning to Olga. “We’re just starting out on Spanish.”

 

Pina’s phone rings during lunch. It’s an unfamiliar San Francisco number so she doesn’t answer it. When a call comes from the same number five minutes later she excuses herself from the table. It could be Vince on somebody else’s phone, for all she knows. She walks out to Charlie’s deck and answers.

“Hello, is this Pina?”
“Yes, this is she.”
“This is Andre, Sylvie’s son. She gave me your number. She tells me you’ve been very kind to her.”
“Is anything wrong?”
“I don’t know. Have you seen her today?”
“No, we had a nice conversation yesterday.”
“I haven’t been able to get in touch with her, either last night or this morning.”

Pina feels tightness gripping her chest; her breathing quickly become shallower. No, she thinks, not an asthma attack. She tells herself to stay calm.

“I wonder if you would mind checking on her? I’d drive up myself, but my wife is away and I’m alone with three kids. There’s a key to the front door under the welcome mat.”
“Alright,” she says, breathless. “I’ll call you back. I’m not home; it might take me a little while to get over there.”

Pina manages to calm herself, but wants her rescue inhaler. She pictures where she left it, in the cabinet under the sink in the main bathroom. She hadn’t used one for years, and recently got a new one. She even forced herself to inhale some of a metered dose before driving up from the city. The inhaler worked and there were quite a number of remaining doses.

“I need to get something back at my place,” she says as she walks purposely past Charlie and Olga.
“Is everything okay?” Charlie asks.

She keeps walking toward the door. “Back in a flash,” she says over her shoulder, knowing full well that she won’t be. Down the steps, she holds tightly on to the railing, stepping as slowly as an octogenarian. Thankfully, Charlie hasn’t opened the door to look after her.

On the way across the grounds to Vince’s condo, she counts very slowly. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. This used to be her routine when the asthma plagued her regularly. She never counted past eight and doesn’t try it now.

Pina stands a distance from Sylvie’s door and gazes at the welcome mat under which the key should be. First she needs her inhaler. She considers the steps up to the condo and begins the count again.

The inhaler is exactly where she pictured it. Within five minutes she feels the medicine work, the muscles in her airways begin to relax, and yet the prospect of going back down the stairs and looking in on Sylvie, dead or alive, is daunting. Her resistance to asking Charlie to join her is just her same old bullshit need to assert her independence at all costs. Who cares about that now? She taps Charlie’s number. She should tell him that he’s now the first name on her favorite’s list.

“Charlie, can you come by my place quickly?
“Sure, sure. Are you okay?”
“Just come, and bring your mask and some gloves for both of us.”
“Roger. And Olga?”
“Leave her with Roscoe. Tell her to take a tour of Arrow Wilk’s paintings and your wrestling masks.”

Pina goes slowly back down the stairs. She’s breathing easier now. She has Sylvie’s key in her hand by the time Charlie arrives, masked and gloved. He hands her a matching pair of purple gloves. As she slips on her gloves, she has a rogue thought—she’d like to play patty-cake with Charlie in purple gloves—but finally forces herself back to the present.

“I’m afraid Sylvie may have done the deed. That was her son on the phone; he hasn’t been able to get in touch with her. I think it’s safe to go in here. Sylvie hasn’t been out of this place in months. She has all her food and meals delivered.”

She and Charlie look warily at each other and then he grabs her hand and holds it a minute. He is a kind man. She knocks on the door, waits, and knocks again. Now she hands the key to Charlie. It is a way of asking for help. She stands behind him as he opens the door.

“Stay back,” he barks, and that is exactly what she does. He repeats his order and adds, “I’ll tell you when the coast is clear.”

She stands in the small hallway just inside the door. Charlie steps deliberately toward the main room. In a cracked voice, he calls, “She’s here . . . dead. You don’t have to see this. You better not see this.”

“Better not,” she mutters. Pina’s lightheaded, but her shortness of breath hasn’t returned. Still she pulls out her inhaler and honks on it. And then there was Sylvie. She sees her standing in her creamy purple blouse with the black scarab, her wedge of white hair, once symbolic of her alacrity, a bit disheveled with the times.

Pina creeps, one sideways-step after another, to the main room.

Charlie hears her. “Better not, Pina.”

She hasn’t a choice. “Oh my God!” Sylvie is on the floor. The way she’s laying on her side, Pina can only see one of her eyes. A shallow pool of blood has formed beside her head and a thick trail of ants is visiting.

“I didn’t want you to see, Pina.”
“Had to.”
“I’ve tried to keep the ants away from her. I think we should lay something over her.”

Pina grabs a towel from the linen closet and comes close to Sylvie for a moment, just getting a quick glimpse—a cubist profile of Sylvie—before Charlie stretches the towel over her head.

“I don’t think she killed herself,” he says. “Can’t see how she could have.”

There’s a tall overturned stool not far from her body and a spray bottle of kitchen and bathroom cleaner close by.

“You think it’s an accident with the stool?”
“Or a heart attack.”

Pina notices the civilization of ants coming down the wall in two rows. “She was up on the stool firing Parsley Plus at the ants when she tipped over.”

“I guess it was her time,” Charlie says.

Pina bows her head. She hardly knew the woman. They may have become good friends in a post-plague world.

Charlie comes over and holds her. Finally, she lets herself cry. In a couple of minutes Pina steps clear of Charlie’s embrace. “I need to call Sylvie’s son. Why don’t you go tell Olga what’s happened. I’m going to stay with Sylvie until her son arrives.”

 

CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN

THE CANARY

 

 

As Pina counts the Japanese eggplants that have sprouted—a bounty that she couldn’t have imagined—she calls down to Sylvie, who she hears putzing with her roses.

“Isn’t it a beautiful morning, Sylvie?”
“Yes, it is. That’s one thing I’ll say for Sonoma—the weather is extraordinary. Coming from Seattle, and Minnesota before that, I almost feel like it’s unfair. Shouldn’t we have to make up for it in some way? I don’t know, pay a good weather tax.”
“That’s funny,” says Pina, “very Puritan of you.” The trouble is she’s never sure about Sylvie’s humor, but what can you expect from a woman who spoke at length about taking her own life.

Pina moves over to her galvanized planter of basils and peppers. “Hey, Sylvie, would you like some of my surplus sweet basil? It’s growing faster than I can use it.”

“Oh, that would be nice. If I only had pine nuts I could make a pesto.”
“I’d offer you some if I had them, but you can also use walnuts, which I don’t have either.”
“Neither do I.”

They speculate on what peanut pesto would be like, as Sylvie has a bag of shelled peanuts.

“I think it would taste like a Thai dish,” Pina says, “and for that matter I can offer you some Thai basil.”
“Golly, suddenly the world is my oyster.”

There goes her humor again. Pina decides to let the matter of the basil rest. They are visible to each other now. Sylvie’s head is tilted back, looking up at Pina, who finds herself studying the rings around the older woman’s neck as if these uneven circles represented the aging of a very mature tree. Clearly, the conversation is not yet done, which Pina takes as a good omen—perhaps her downstairs neighbor plans to stick around for the duration.

“How’s your boyfriend?” Sylvie asks, unexpectedly.
“You mean, Charlie?”
“Well, I don’t know how many boyfriends you have, Pina.”

Is Sylvie being hostile now?

“The one who lives here in the complex.”
“That’s Charlie.”
“Charlie,” Sylvie repeats as if she were committing a difficult name to memory. “Charlie sounds like an interesting man. I hear the two of you sometimes when you’re talking out on the deck. I know I shouldn’t listen, but I can’t help myself. You two are better than daytime TV.”

Pina feels herself blush. What exactly has Sylvie heard? Does she hear them when they make love, as well?

“Charlie has a parrot, doesn’t he?”
“Right. Roscoe.”
“Roscoe. And I’ve heard you say that Charlie has taught Roscoe not only to speak, but to reason with language.”
“Reasoning might be a reach. I don’t think Roscoe is going to attain great heights of cognition.”
“But, still, a thinking bird. Anyway, Charlie sounds like a very kind man. He’s sweet to you. Don’t take that for granted.” Sylvie eyes fix meaningfully on Pina.

She nods. It’s true, of course, what Sylvie is saying, but something about her forthright manner is unnerving. She senses herself wanting to withdraw from Sylvie’s intense gaze.

“Pina, I want to give you a piece of advice that my mother gave me when I was young—when you find a kind man, hold onto him.”

She feels a lump in her throat and can think of only a single word in response: “Thanks,” which feels criminally insufficient.

“I followed my mother’s advice,” Sylvie continues, her eyes softening into memory, “and I’m very glad I did.”

 

Two hours later, Pina is still replaying the conversation with Sylvie. She wonders if Vince could be described as kind. Surely, he’s been kind at times, but kindness more than likely wouldn’t make a top ten list of adjectives to describe him, a list that would include charming, self-absorbed, good-looking, clever, jazz-loving, superior, contemptuous. She quits before enumerating any further, as the attributes drifts further from Sylvie’s mark.

At Charlie’s, during lunch—an omelet she whips up with shallots, gruyere, and plenty of basil—she tells him about her conversation with Sylvie, without mentioning the kindness bit.

“We can’t talk anymore when we’re on the deck over there—Sylvie overhears everything we say.”
“Maybe we should spend more time there, Pina,” Charlie says with a mouth full of omelet, “we’re keeping her alive. We’ve become her raison d’être.”
“Very funny. She probably hears us when we make love.”
“Then we should make love more often.”
“You’re shameless, Charlie.”

He wipes his mouth with his napkin and bends toward her, kissing the tip of her long nose. “Ti amo, Pina, Ti amo.”

Not only is he kind, he’s irresistible.

 

After lunch they watch Erich von Stroheim’s 1924 masterpiece “Greed” on one of Charlie’s huge computer monitors. It seems wrong to her to watch a film during a sunny day, but Charlie’s persuasive powers get the better of her. At lunch she mentioned that she’d finally finished reading McTeague, the tale of the San Francisco dentist who’s life goes off the rails, and Charlie insisted they find a link to von Stroheim’s “legendary” film of the novel.

“I haven’t seen it for thirty years,” Charlie said, his face marbling with enthusiasm. “Now that it’s front of mind, I don’t think I can live another day without seeing it.”

Pina has only watched a handful of silent movies in her life—a few Chaplin films and a Buster Keaton or two, so “Greed” is a revelation.

Charlie explains that the original film was seven plus hours but that the studio cut it to two hours and destroyed three quarters of the reels. “The studio burned all but ten of the original forty-five reels,” Charlie says, with fresh outrage, “to extract the bit of silver from the nitrate.” Von Stroheim was devastated and, indeed, when the film starts on Charlie’s computer, the first frame shows a quote from the director:

No matter if I could talk to you three weeks steadily could I describe even to a small degree the heartache I suffered through the mutilation of my sincere work.

Pina has Charlie pause the frame so she can reread the quote. “It’s not even grammatical,” she says.

“Von Stroheim was Austrian and sincere,” Charlie says, kindly. “You know, he saw McTeague as a Greek tragedy.”
“But Charlie, Charlie, Charlie, with all due respect, I can’t see how the demise of a bumbling fool and his miser wife can form the arc of a tragedy.”
“That’s a very elitist view, Pina. It’s really a story about hard-working people who have little but tragedy in their lives.”

She feels mildly chastised, but persists. “If we’re talking about the formal elements of tragedy, I’d have to say that McTeague is closer to bathos.

Charlie makes a clown face at her. “Oh, so you found McTeague bathetic, Pina,” he jokes.

She concentrates on the film now and is taken aback by how much it moves her. The acting is surprisingly good and the frames of spare text are used so efficiently you almost forget that there is no sound. She’s not sure how the director achieves it, but he’s given his characters an elemental quality, perhaps through the mix of stills and motion. Captured in stills, you’re able to see the characters’ souls, their tragedy. Pina’s almost ready to say uncle.

Charlie chirps in from time to time to rave about the director’s innovations. “Look at how many angles he shoots from. Can you imagine the lighting he had to set up to achieve the deep focus? And all of it on location, from San Francisco to Death Valley.” Charlie tells her that Stroheim filmed in Death Valley for two months in high summer to capture the scenes that take place there.

All along, Pina considers the simple man, McTeague, content with his practice in his “dental parlors.” He has humble pleasures: his pitcher of steam beer on Sunday, the six songs that he can play on his concertina, and his canary in its gilded cage. When McTeague’s new wife wins the lottery, the giant oaf loses all of his comforts. But does the story rise to the level of tragedy? No, she won’t let that question alone. Do any of our lives merit such a designation? She thinks of Vince. She can’t stop thinking of Vince. If he were to succumb to opioids, would his fall from princely doctor qualify as tragedy? If Sylvie takes her own life is that tragedy? She thinks not. And yet, who is she kidding with her formal charade? Why is she trying to insulate herself?

She remembers a conversation she had years ago with Vince about symbolism. She pointed out something as being symbolic—the fact that she can no longer remember what it was underscores the point of Vince’s response, which still chills her to the bone.

“Pina,” the would-be poet said with the coolness of a surgeon, “everything is symbolic.”

She finds something touching about McTeague, even while he’s on the lam for murder. He is so damn human in his foibles. His trail leads in circles. Although he tortures and kills the wife who brought suffering to his life, he is kind to his burro. And then there is the canary, the only thing he manages to keep with him until the end. He carries the bird in its cage, through the mining camps and straight into Death Valley, squandering some of his scarce water to keep damp flour cloths over the birdcage. Finally, at least in Stroheim’s version, he lets the bird free from its cage. They are both doomed. McTeague hears the bird’s final chirps right before his own death rattle begins.

 

This evening Charlie calls her from his television headquarters. “Pina, come have a drink with me.”
“Alright, be there in a minute.”

That’s about the only thing he could say to get her to his back room, where Roscoe perches in his cage. Charlie has become a news hound; he can’t get enough of it. He’ll sit for hours listening to CNN and MSNBC. Sometimes he even tunes into Fox News, just to get a look at the enemy’s spin. She hardly ever joins him in front of the TV.

Charlie’s trained the parrot to caw: “TRUMP, THE RAVING NARCISSIST,” every time the president’s name is mentioned. To Pina, these news shows are an endless loop of bluster. The host prompts the talking heads to spout outrage, and they then find ingenious ways to agree with each other.

Pina’s just pulled a chicken out of the fridge and turns electric stove to 475. It’s Mario Batali’s recipe, Balsamic Roast Chicken. She feels guilty for using it, given that Batali’s history of abusing women has been fully chronicled. But the chicken is so damn good, and Batali probably pirated the recipe from some old world Italian years ago. Pina salted and peppered the chicken three hours ago and stuffed it with two thickly sliced onions, three pieces of prosciutto, and a hardy rind of Parmigiano-Reggiano. When the bird comes back to room temperature in the roasting pan, she’ll pour a cup of Lambrusco over it and rub it down with two tablespoons of balsamic. The chicken, roasted at so high a temp, will be sumptuous with the onions, and render a marvelous gravy. She’ll serve it atop three heads of buttered and broiled radicchio, with a side of basmati rice cooked in the broth from the last Batali chicken.

She mixes herself a second Campari spritz. Charlie will be nursing his martini until dinner.

“So what’s the news?” she asks.
“Pina, Pina, Pina, where you beena?” squawks Roscoe.
“What’s the good word, Roscoe?”
“Word, word, I know a thousand words,” brags the parrot.
“The only good news,” Charlie says, “is that Donald Trump isn’t getting any good news.”
“TRUMP, THE RAVING NARCISSIST.”
“His poll numbers are in the toilet, his hateful rallies are sparsely attended, and now with Russians paying bounties for the killing of American troops, there is pressure on the child monster to explain his trust of Putin over our intelligence agencies.
“Actually there’s more good news. The state of Mississippi is taking the confederate reference off their flags; confederate statues continue to tumble; more and more rogue cops are getting arrested; police departments may not be defunded but their monies are being reallocated; the Washington Redskins are changing their name, and the Cleveland Indians are considering changing theirs. I’ve always had a soft spot for that much-loathed city since they got the rock & roll museum. I think the baseball team should change their name to the Cleveland Rock & Rolls, and then rebuild the city with a bunch of music clubs.”
“Any new Karen out there?” Pina asks. She’s taken particular pleasure in watching one raging white woman after another self-immolate on social media. After seeing a video of a woman go berserk in a supermarket, tossing her groceries out of her cart when told she had to wear a face mask, Pina wondered if she’d be capable of such irrational rage.
“You saw the couple out front of their St. Louis mansion with an assault weapon and a handgun. I think that they’re the latest Ken and Karen.”
“Charlie, do you think America is going to devolve into fear and loathing?”
“Some of it already has. That’s Trump’s specialty.”
“TRUMP, THE RAVING NARCISSIST.”
“You’ve created a monster, Charlie.”
“I know.”
“Can’t we run away? Get out of this country.”
“It’s not a bad idea, Pina, but there’s no place to go. We’re Americans, no other country will accept us. Not Canada. Not Europe.”
“Can’t we sneak into Mexico?”
“We better do it quickly. Mexico will be shutting the border soon. The state of Sonora, beneath Arizona’s flashpoint, is considering shutting down right now, and if we get caught trying to sneak across, Mexico will keep us in internment camps for the foreseeable future.”
“So in other words, we’re under house arrest.”
“You could say that, but at least we have each other.”
“And you think that’s a good thing, Charlie?”
“I do.”
“I do too.” Pina pours down the rest of her Campari. “Just don’t let me drink myself to death while you nurse that damn martini.”

Charlie smiles at her.

“You know what Sylvie said about you, Charlie? She said you were kind, and I don’t think she was mistaken.”

The buzzer of the electric stove asserts itself; it’s time to put the chicken in.

 

CHAPTER TWENTY-SIX

THE BERGAMASCO SHEPPARD

 

 

Pina decides to keep her birthday to herself, but a flurry of phone calls come from old friends, and she feels pleased to be remembered, if guilty for being so out of touch since the plague began. She hasn’t spoken with her old chum Olga once in the last months and is sorry to hear how the Coronavirus has turned Olga’s life upside down. Her elderly parents both died in April from the virus and Olga’s lost all of her work as a yoga instructor. On top of that, Stephen, Olga’s longtime boyfriend, recently moved in with his boyfriend Geoff, a relationship he’d been having on the sly for years.

“I’m waiting to get cancer,” Olga says. “It’s been suspiciously quiet around here lately, although pretty soon I will be evicted and have to move into my parents’ house in Modesto, which will represent death on the installment plan.”
“Why didn’t you call?” Pina asks.
“The same reason you didn’t.”

Pina wonders what that reason is, but isn’t curious enough to probe the question. She and Olga had been best friends during college and for years after, but after Marco died, Pina pulled away from many of her old friends, preferring solitary grieving to the cloying pity of others. Olga was a friend she later reunited with, but the friendship didn’t resume as it had been.

Pina doctors her Bloody Mary mix with Worcestershire, Tabasco, and smashed garlic. She’s been on a sobriety kick since Sylvie called her a noisy drunk, but today is her birthday, for God’s sakes.

“So what’s it like spending all those months in the country?” Olga asks.
“I wouldn’t exactly call Sonoma the country.” A jigger and a half of vodka, and voilà.
“Compared to a funky apartment in the Lower Height, it’s the fucking wilderness. So, what’s the deal with you and Vince? Have you found that you enjoy each other more being separated?”
“I think that’s about right.” She’s resolved not to say anything about what’s happened to Vince, but for some reason she tells Olga about Charlie and can sense her friend’s gossip consciousness springing to life.
“Is it serious, Pina?”
“I don’t know.”
“What’s he like?”
“Like nobody I’ve ever known. He’s kind of a wizard geek dude.”
“A wizard geek dude. What the fuck is that, Pina? Does he have a particularly big wand?”
“Don’t talk dirty, Olga.”
“Why the fuck not?”

Olga, always one of the most straight-laced of Pina’s friends—she was raised a Christian Scientist and evolved into a devout practitioner of Transcendental Meditation—has discovered the value of obscenity, pitching fucking this and fucking that everywhere now that both her parents have died and the Coronavirus has turned all of us into existentialists. Pina takes a bite of her Bloody-laced celery.

“Are you eating, Pina?”
“Yes, I’m eating my Bloody Mary.”
“That sounds good. Okay, describe a wizard geek dude, Pina.”
“Oh, he’s indescribable.” Pina wanders out to the deck and sees Sylvie in her garden. She waves furiously to Sylvie until she’s spotted and points to her phone and shrugs. Another night survived; the suicide watch is lightening up.
“Come on, Pina, tell me about Charlie.”
She walks back inside. “Okay, for one thing, he’s not only trained his parrot Roscoe to talk, he’s trained him to think.”
“Get out.”
“I’m not kidding.”
“So you’re having an affair with the wizard geek, parrot master in your husband’s condo.”
Pina swirls what’s left of her Bloody around in the glass. “Vince isn’t really my husband and Charlie and I spend most of the time over at his place.”
“Technicalities. You’re hiding behind technicalities, Pina.”
“I’m not hiding.”
“Vince knows?”
“No, no, no, no, no. And I don’t want any gossip from you, Olga.”
“Wouldn’t think of it. So, tell me, can I come up and meet the wizard geek? I’ll wear my mask.”
“You sure you’re willing to venture into the wilderness, Olga?”
“I’m ready for anything.”
“Then come on up next week.”
“Do you think the guy knows another wizard geek dude?”
“I’ll enquire.”
“Alright, Pina, now that I know you’re going to have a happy birthday, I can let you go.”

 

The next call is the one that really takes her by surprise.
“Happy birthday, darling.”
“Vince, where are you?”
“Not to worry. I’m where I’m supposed to be, at Harmony Acres in Nicasio. They gave me my phone back the other day, but I thought I’d wait for your birthday to call.”
He sounds normal, whatever that means. “It’s good to hear your voice, Vince.”
“And yours, darling. Of course, all I want to do is apologize to you, Pina. I sure as hell went off the deep end and I’m so sorry to have put you through hell.”
“You’re the one who went through hell, Vince, and I hope you don’t go back.” Pina walks briefly back out onto the deck, squeezes the Thai basil and admires the majesty of the Japanese eggplant. Sylvie is nowhere to be seen now.
“I don’t intend to go back to that madness, but they say that being here is the easy part.”
“What’s the place like, Vince?” Pina mixes herself another Bloody Mary, a bit sorry to be drinking alone.
“The grounds are nice and they let you go for walks in the morning. There’s a dairy farm nearby and I walk by everyday and talk to the cows. They’re about the best company I have. Almost all the clients are half my age or younger. Some of them even call me gramps. They’ve gotten a bit kinder since I’ve started cooking dinner.”
“You’re cooking dinner?”
“Yeah, they found out I could cook so that’s become my job. Dinner’s gotten a lot better, I must say. Otherwise, we have three daily meetings, meet individually with a counselor, and write heaps in our notebooks everyday. Shame seems to be the subject I keep swimming through. It’s a real cesspool. The big news is I’ve gotten back to writing poems. I say back as if I’d taken a brief sabbatical, but it’s been more than forty years since I’ve written a poem.”
“That’s wonderful, Vince.”
“Yeah, look what it took me to get back to writing. But I wrote a poem for you, Pina. I wonder if you’d be willing to let me read it.”
“Of course.” Actually, Vince doesn’t really sound normal. There’s something different about him she can’t put her finger on. It’s as if a bit of humility has crept into his personality, but she reminds herself that it may only be a new manner he’s adopted.
“It’s called Calves. For Pina.”

        It’s good to see the heifer calves
        run free on a dairy farm.
        They’ll likely have a full life.
        The bull calves have another fate.
        Do you remember the day
        we came upon a village of calf huts
        on the road to Point Reyes?
        You asked me to stop the car
        at the side of the road.
        The calves, chained to their huts,
        could only move a few feet.
        They lay on their haunches
        and had already given up their spirits.
        Why, you wondered, why do they keep them like that?
        We both knew it was to prevent them
        from building muscle.
        Tenderness is what’s treasured in a calf,
        and in a lover.
        I watched you cry
        as if they were human children.
        Compassion has always been your strong suit.
        It’s never come naturally to me.
        I am trying to discover that quality in myself
        and believe it exists less between my ears
        than in my heart.
        That’s a staunchly defended territory, hard to reach.
        You should know that a lifetime
        of bad habits and lazy reckonings
        are tattooed to my psyche
       What can I promise you?

 

Pina waits for more lines, but the poem is over. “Gosh, that’s powerful, Vince.” She got tangled in the lines, though certain phrases haunted her: Tenderness is what’s treasured in a calf, and in a lover; Bad habits and lazy reckonings; and What can I promise you? Now she wonders what more can she say about his poem. “It sounds like you’ve been digging deep Vince.”

“Do you think? I’m not so sure. It all might be mood making. I don’t trust myself, and when I realize how much my shtick is a part of me—a load of flim flam competence—changing myself after all these years seems impossible. You know what they say about old dogs. But it’s become a very clear choice for me, Pina: I either tilt the windmills of sobriety or go off like a mad dog into the night.”

Mad dog, she thinks, pronouncing the words in her mind. Pina, carelessly, pours down the rest of her Bloody Mary and her throat catches fire.

“Forgive me, Pina, for laying all this shit on you. This was supposed to be a birthday call.”
Pina gasps before she is able to respond. “So when do you get out, Vince?”
“Ten days. It’s very scary.”
“Can you sign on for another month?”
“I might be able to, but I want to get back to the real world and take on the challenge. I spoke with Bernard the other day and he’s arranged for a couple people to clean out the damage I did to the house. It will be two guys in Hazmat suits and cost a small fortune. Can I see you, Pina? Can we try to start over?”
“I’d be happy to see you, Vince—from a distance. That’s all I can say for now.”
“From a distance,” he mumbles, and now, in his new humble voice says, “I understand. I perfectly understand. Send me good thoughts, Pina, and enjoy your day.”

 

Before she can make herself a third Bloody Mary, Charlie arrives at the door with a large package for her. She’d forgotten that she’d told him when her birthday was, many weeks ago. She welcomes him inside and offers him a Bloody.

“I better stay with coffee.” He’s still wary of drink after his recent three-martini night. He takes her into his arms. “Happy birthday, Pina.”

She can’t get Vince out of her head and tries to force herself into the present. “You didn’t have to get me anything, Charlie.” She takes the box with her and leads him into the second bedroom, where he settles into the leather La-Z-Boy.

When she comes back with coffee and a glass of rosé for herself, he says, “Three guesses what’s in the box.”

She makes a show of shaking it; it’s denser than she expected. “I don’t have a clue.”

“Here’s one.” Charlie breaks into song:

        “How much is that doggie in the window?
The one with the waggly tail
How much is that doggie in the window?
I do hope that doggie’s for sale.

        I must take a trip from California
And leave my poor sweetheart alone
If she has a dog, she won’t be lonesome
And the doggie will have a good home.

 Charlie’s voice wobbles back to careful speech. “My big sister Alba sang that to me when I was a child, but I never got the dog. Open it, Pina.”

She rips the paper and lifts the lid from the box. It’s a stuffed animal. A charming and densely hairy dog, its coat, woven of browns and grays, covers its eyes. She sweeps away the hair on each side and is delighted to find its deep brown eyes.

“It’s a Bergamasco Sheppard, Pina. Didn’t you say your people were from Bergamo? This one may have wintered in Bergamo, but he was native to the Alps.”
“Where did you find it, Charlie?”
“That’s my secret.”

And then she discovers the discreet label: Fialdini’s, Bergamo.

“You sent to Bergamo for this?”
He smiles at her, pleased with himself. “Let’s just say, I didn’t re-gift it.”
Pina’s squeezes the animal. The girl in her—when she allowed herself to be the girl—would have loved this large dog, and she adores it now.
“What are you going to name him, Pina?”
She sweeps the hair from its eyes. “Giovanni. His name’s Giovanni.”
“Perfecto.”
“How does that song go again?”
Charlie sings it even more sweetly than he did the first time.

        “How much is that doggie in the window?
The one with the waggly tail
How much is that doggie in the window?
I do hope that doggie’s for sale.

 She thinks of Charlie never getting his dog and then of Vince, turning into a mad dog. Be with the one you’re with. She smiles at her wizard geek. “You can share Giovanni with me, Charlie. He can be ours.”